Copyright Forstner Law.  All rights reserved.

Request an Appointment

Contact
Forstner Law
21 Simcoe St. S.
Oshawa, ON. L1H 4G1
Tel: 289-316-2573
Fax: 289-275-2226
Direct: 289-316-2578
Toll Free: 877-315-3375
Cell: 289-387-1911
Lawrence@ForstnerLaw.ca

At paragraph 56 of the decision the court spells out why crown discretion must be scrutinized on some occasions.  What seems clear to others is sometimes lost on a crown, when they live in a world where they know their behind the scenes actions will not be second guessed.  Second guessing keeps people honest in all halls of power.  The court says:


"I would conclude the appellant has met the threshold evidentiary burden on the basis that the offer here was a "rare and exceptional event". The offer itself and the circumstances in which it was made are sufficient to raise the court's concern about the Crown's exercise of discretion. It constituted, in effect, an offer made directly to the accused and, given its nature, had the potential to negatively affect the relationship between the appellant and his lawyers. The proper functioning of the relationship between an accused and defence counsel is crucial to the proper administration of criminal justice."


In the end, the conviction was overturned and sent back for a new trial, so the “abuse of process” allegation could be fully argued.

Shining Light Under the Cover of Crown Discretion

Phone: (289) 316-2573

Call Now: (289) 316-2573

Legal Aid Clients Welcome

21 Simcoe St. S. Oshawa L1H 4G1@CORE21

Origins of the Forstner Law Logo

Forstner Law

Oversight Keeps the Crown in Check

Click on R v Delchev to read the whole case.


Because of the crown's untoward offer, the accused asked for a stay of his charges; the crown was engaging in “abuse of process".  Abuse of process will only get a stay “in the rarest of cases” and not normally just because of an act of crown discretion that we might disagree with.  But when it goes to an issue that is important to the administration of justice, the court will intervene.

Legal Aid Clients Welcome

Terms:
Please consult a lawyer for advice about your individual situation.  This site and its information is not legal advice, nor is it meant to be.  Feel free to get in touch by electronic mail, letters, or phone calls.  Contacting us does not create a solicitor-client relationship.  Until a solicitor-client relationship is established, please withhold from sending any confidential information to us.

Office Locations: Forstner Law has offices right near the Oshawa Courthouse on Simcoe St. S. Lawrence  regularly makes house calls and occasionally sees clients in his home office in Ajax.

Serving Oshawa, Brooklin, Pickering, Whitby, Ajax, the GTA and the Durham Region

Lawrence Forstner, Criminal Lawyer in Oshawa, Expert Qualifications and Specialized Training:
Former Crown Attorney;  Former Probation & Parole Officer;  Ontario Domestic Assault Risk Assessment (ODARA), Sex Offender Risk Assessment, Strategic Initiatives in Community Supervision (STICS), Sex Offender Relapse Prevention, Substance Use / Anger Management Group Leader/ Trainer.   (
https://ca.linkedin.com/in/forstnerlaw )

GET DIRECTIONS

When "Unfettered Discretion" Isn't


 R v Delchev is about an attempt by the crown to get the accused to throw his own lawyer under the bus.  The crown offered a better deal if the accused testified that he lied under oath, and his own lawyer knew he was doing it.


This case stresses the importance of  the relationship between you and your lawyer, and, it explains how to assess whether to attack the exercise of crown discretion.


Normally, the crown has “unfettered discretion.”  But when the crown attempts to damage the client-lawyer relationship, it might be an abuse of process. The lesson?  Do watch carefully; if it doesn’t smell right, let me know, we can hold them accountable

R v Delchev